Jason (jcreed) wrote,

neelk pointed me to A λ-calculus for resource separation by Bob Atkey. He also talked a bit about what Carsten Varming did last summer. Carsten tried to explain it to me in the elevator the other day, but I didn't get it then. It has something to do with a constructive development in Coq of domain theory. The cute thing about it is the fact that, morally, the nontermination monad isn't (as I sort of passively thought it was) the same as the exception monad λX.X+1, which provides a single other computational alternative to returning a value of type X. How you should think of it is the type operator λX.να.X+α, which given a type X returns the coinductive stream type να.X+α, which you can read as "eventually maybe X". All you can do with the stream is ask it to unroll one step, at which point you find either the long-sought X you were hoping against hope to find, or again να.X+α telling you to keep waiting another day*.

Anyway I thought this was a nice and utterly syntactically simple way of capturing the fact that nontermination is a computational process and not an alternative value. It is in fact a monad. (good exercise: what is its μ?)

I uploaded a half-dozen pages of notes on how to do "full" linear logic in labelled style to my drafts page. The big surprise is that additive falsehood ("0") breaks spectacularly. I'm also missing the exponential, but I've sketched that out enough in other places that I'm pretty sure it works.

Anyway big thanks are owed to the ultra-slick higher-order completeness lemma that came out of Frank and simrob's recent work.

*coinductive types also wish you a happy valentine's day. Γ ⊢ να.(♥ + α), I guess?
Tags: papers

  • (no subject)

    Didn't sleep well. Long day of work. Dinner with akiva at hanamichi.

  • (no subject)

    K was going to do a thing for her dad's birthday, but scheduling kept slipping and slipping so I guess we're going to try doing it tomorrow instead.

  • (no subject)

    Had a pleasant lunch with paul and gabe back from working-at-facebook times. Discussed the important issues of the day, by which I mean video games…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded